Are you wondering when to replace a toilet? Let’s flush it out in this article. Knowing when to replace a toilet depends on several factors, including the toilet's age, condition, and performance.
Click on each link to learn more:
1. Signs of When to Replace a Toilet
2. Signs of When to Repair Your Toilet
Trust WaterSmart to help you with any plumbing-related issues. We’ve been proudly serving the Waterloo Region for close to 30 years. Let us put our expertise to work for you.
1. Signs of when to replace a toilet
Here are some signs that indicate it might be time to replace your toilet:
Frequent Repairs
If you find yourself frequently fixing issues with your toilet, such as constantly running water, leaks, or problems with flushing, it might be more cost-effective to replace it rather than continue with repairs.
Cracks or Damage
Inspect the porcelain bowl and tank for cracks, chips, or other visible damage. Cracks can lead to leaks and other problems over time.
Chronic Clogs
If your toilet consistently clogs, even after attempts to clear the blockage, it may be a sign of an inefficient or outdated toilet. Newer toilets are designed to have better flushing capabilities.
Water Efficiency
Older toilets use significantly more water per flush compared to newer, low-flow models. Replacing an older toilet with a more water-efficient one can save you money on your water bill over time.
Toilet Wobbling
A wobbly toilet can indicate a problem with the wax ring seal or a damaged flange. If the toilet isn't securely anchored, it can lead to leaks or even sewage backup.
Stains or Odors
Stubborn stains that can't be removed or persistent odours that linger even after cleaning could be a sign that the porcelain is compromised or that there are issues with the wax ring seal.
Aging Toilet
If your toilet is more than 20 years old, it's likely less water-efficient and may not meet current plumbing standards. Replacing it with a newer model can improve efficiency and functionality.
Energy Rebates or Incentives
In some regions, there are energy efficiency incentives or rebates for replacing older toilets with water-saving models. Check with your local utility company to see if you qualify for any programs.
Style and Aesthetics
If you're remodelling your bathroom and the toilet's style or colour doesn't match your new design, it might be a good time to replace it for aesthetic reasons.
Environmental Considerations
If you're environmentally conscious, replacing an old toilet with a low-flow or dual-flush model can reduce water consumption and have a positive impact on the environment.
2. Signs of when to repair your toilet
Deciding whether to repair or replace your toilet depends on the specific issue, the age and condition of the toilet, and your budget. Here's a guide to help you make that decision:
Minor Leaks
If you notice a small leak around the base of the toilet, it may be due to a damaged wax ring or loose bolts. These issues are typically repairable and don't require a full replacement.
Running Water
If your toilet continues to run after flushing, it may be due to a faulty flapper valve, which is a relatively simple and inexpensive repair.
Clogs
Occasional clogs can often be resolved with a plunger or a plumbing snake. Frequent clogs may indicate a larger issue with your plumbing, which may require a professional assessment.
Cosmetic Issues
If the toilet has minor cosmetic issues, such as scratches or stains, these can usually be addressed with cleaning or minor touch-ups.
Handle and Flush Mechanism Issues
Problems with the toilet handle or flush mechanism, like a broken handle or chain, are usually easy and inexpensive to fix.
Before deciding whether or not your toilet needs repaired or replaced, it's often a good idea to consult with a professional plumber who can assess the specific issues with your toilet and provide recommendations.
They can help you weigh the costs of repairs versus replacement and ensure that your plumbing is in good working order. Ultimately, your choice should align with your budget, needs, and long-term goals for your bathroom.
3. How to replace a toilet
Once you’ve determined when to replace a toilet, it can be a moderately complex DIY project, but it's manageable if you have some plumbing experience and the right tools. Here's a step-by-step guide to help you replace a toilet:
Tools and Materials You'll Need:
New toilet (with wax ring and bolts included)
Adjustable wrench
Screwdriver
Plumber's putty (optional)
Hacksaw (for cutting bolts if needed)
Bucket and sponge
Rags or towels
Pipe wrench (optional)
Closet bolts and flange repair kit (if needed)
Safety Precautions:
Turn off the water supply to the toilet by shutting the shut-off valve located near the base of the toilet or at the water supply line.
Wear gloves and eye protection when working with the toilet to maintain hygiene and prevent any debris from getting into your eyes.
Steps to Replace a Toilet:
1. Remove the Old Toilet:
Flush the toilet to remove most of the water from the tank and bowl.
Disconnect the water supply line from the fill valve at the bottom of the tank. Use an adjustable wrench to loosen the nut.
Remove the caps covering the closet bolts (the bolts securing the toilet to the floor). Use a screwdriver to remove any nuts or washers securing the toilet to the floor.
Carefully lift the old toilet off the closet flange (the pipe fitting in the floor) and set it aside. Be prepared for residual water, so have a bucket and sponge ready.
2. Prepare the Area:
Inspect the closet flange for damage. If it's broken or corroded, you may need to replace it with a flange repair kit.
Scrape off any remaining wax or putty from the closet flange. Clean the area thoroughly.
3. Install the new wax ring:
Place a new wax ring onto the closet flange. The wax ring should fit snugly over the flange, creating a watertight seal.
If the closet flange is below the finished floor level (common in some installations), you may need to use an extra-thick wax ring or a spacer to ensure a proper seal.
4. Set the New Toilet:
Carefully position the new toilet over the wax ring and closet bolts, ensuring they pass through the holes in the base of the toilet.
Press the toilet down gently to compress the wax ring and create a seal.
5. Secure the Toilet:
Place washers and nuts onto the closet bolts and tighten them evenly to secure the toilet to the floor. Be careful not to over-tighten, as this can crack the toilet base.
Cover the closet bolt nuts with the provided caps or decorative covers.
6. Reconnect the Water Supply:
Reattach the water supply line to the fill valve at the bottom of the toilet tank. Hand-tighten the nut, and then use an adjustable wrench to give it a quarter-turn for a secure connection.
Slowly turn on the water supply by opening the shut-off valve.
7. Check for Leaks:
Let the tank fill, and check for any leaks around the base of the toilet and at the water supply connection.
8. Flush and Test:
Flush the toilet a few times to ensure it's working correctly and there are no leaks.
9. Finish Up:
If there is any excess wax visible around the base of the toilet, you can trim it with a utility knife.
Attach the toilet seat according to the manufacturer's instructions.
Congratulations, you've successfully replaced your toilet! Dispose of the old toilet properly, either by taking it to a recycling centre or arranging for a waste disposal service.
Still unsure about when to replace a toilet? We can help.
Whether you need to replace an old toilet or you are installing a new one into a new home, the professionals at WaterSmart can help. We will provide you with:
THOROUGH DIAGNOSIS
We will do a thorough inspection of your toilet to provide you with an accurate diagnosis. We will discuss your options with you and answer any questions you might have.
AFFORDABLE QUOTE
We won't pressure you to do any repair or installation that you are not comfortable with. We will give you an honest quote, with no hidden fees, before we attempt any repairs.
EXCEPTIONAL SERVICE
Your time is important so we will make sure that we arrive at your home at the time you agreed to. Once we have completed the work to your satisfaction, we will leave your home as we found it.
“Hired their plumbers to rough in a washroom in my basement. Very skillful, knowledgeable and polite technicians. They took away the debris and cleaned the area carefully after they finished. They are willing to answer any of your questions. They took ownership of their jobs! If you are looking for a trust able plumber, this team is definitely your best choice!”
